AEVOMIND INSIGHTS — NGOs & CHARITIES
Reporting a serious incident to the Charity Commission: what trustees must report, how fast, and how software keeps the record

The Charity Commission's guidance says trustees must report a serious incident promptly, as soon as reasonably possible after it happens or the charity learns of it, and that charities with an income over 25,000 pounds must sign an annual declaration that everything reportable was reported. Trustees decide what is serious, and a decision not to report must be explainable later. Software can keep the register of incidents and decisions, but it cannot decide what is serious.
The short answer
The Charity Commission’s guidance, How to report a serious incident in your charity (last updated 16 January 2026), says it needs “prompt, full and frank disclosure to the Commission” when something serious happens. Responsibility sits with the trustees, the test for what is serious is the trustees’ own judgement, and a charity with an income over 25,000 pounds has to sign a declaration each year that it has reported everything it should have.
That makes the record of each incident matter twice: when it happens, and a year later when the declaration is signed. A connected system can hold each incident with its dates, decisions and reference numbers, and make sure none is lost. It cannot decide what is serious or what to say to the Commission. Trustees do that.

What counts, and who decides
The guidance defines a serious incident as “an adverse event, whether actual or alleged, which results in or risks significant” harm to people who come into contact with the charity, loss of money or assets, damage to property, or harm to the charity’s work or reputation. “Significant” is measured against the charity itself.
It names the main categories: safeguarding incidents; financial crime, meaning fraud, theft, cyber-crime and money laundering; large donations from an unknown or unverifiable source or suspicious activity using the charity’s funds; other significant financial loss; links to terrorism or extremism; and other significant incidents such as insolvency, the forced withdrawal of banking services, significant data breaches or losses, and incidents involving partners that materially affect the charity.
On who decides, it is clear: “It is the responsibility of the charity trustees to decide whether an incident is significant and should be reported.” And on size, it declines to set a floor: “There is no minimum loss figure that should be reported”. The higher the value, the more serious the incident is likely to be, and the guidance lists other signs of seriousness, such as a senior person being involved.
How fast, and how to show it
An actual or alleged incident should be reported “as soon as is reasonably possible after it happens, or immediately after your charity becomes aware of it”. Two further points matter for the record. First, trustees are told not to wait for the police: charities should report promptly and “do not wait until someone is arrested, charged or convicted”, and should report to the Commission “even if you have already reported it to the police or another regulator”. Second, a decision not to report has to be defensible: “If you decide not to make a report about something serious that has happened in your charity and the Commission later becomes involved, you will need to be able to explain why you decided not to report it at the time.”
That last sentence is a records requirement in plain language. A borderline decision made in a corridor, with no note, cannot be explained later. The guidance says decisions made by others on whether to report “should be reported back to trustees (particularly where incidents were ‘borderline’ and making a report was considered but it was decided not to make one)”. So the register has to hold the incidents that were not reported as well as the ones that were.

What the report asks for
The Commission’s online form asks for facts that a charity has to collect before it can fill it in. The guidance lists them:
- Who you are: contact details, the charity’s name and registration number, and reference numbers and contacts for any report to the police or another body.
- What happened: the date of the incident, what happened, the date and manner in which the charity found out, the impact on beneficiaries, finances, staff, operations or reputation, and whether trustees are aware.
- How you are handling it: which policies relate to the incident and whether they were followed, the steps taken to deal with it and to prevent similar incidents, and any media handling.
It adds: “It is not necessary to provide the names or any other personal details of any individuals involved in the incident in your initial report”, and the Commission will ask if it needs them. That is helpful for data protection: the register can hold the full case while the report carries only what is needed.
Reports are not one-off either. If there are “material changes to the facts that were reported”, or significant developments, including that someone alleged to be responsible has been exonerated, the charity should tell the Commission as soon as it becomes aware, using the same form and the incident reference number from the confirmation email. That number is a thing to store against the incident.
The annual declaration
For a charity with income over 25,000 pounds, the loop closes in the annual return: the charity must “sign a declaration confirming there were no serious incidents during the previous financial year that should have been reported to the Commission but were not”. If there were incidents that were not reported at the time, the guidance says they should be submitted before filing, so the declaration can be made, and that until all serious incidents have been reported the charity cannot make the declaration or complete the annual return, which is a statutory requirement under section 169 of the Charities Act 2011.
For a trustee board, the practical question is: before signing, can we show that every incident of the year was either reported or consciously judged not to need reporting, and by whom? A register with dates, reference numbers and decisions answers it in minutes. A scatter of emails does not.

What software can do, and what it cannot
The chart below uses illustrative figures, not client data, for a charity with about 40 staff and 200 volunteers.
Illustrative inputs, not client data. Totals: 36 hours a month by hand against 14 with a system. Deciding whether an incident is serious falls least, on purpose: the Commission says it is the trustees' responsibility to decide. A system removes the gathering, assembling and tracking, not the judgement. Substitute hours you have measured.
Show the data
| By hand | With a system | |
|---|---|---|
| Gathering the details from emails and notes when a concern arises | 10 hrs | 3 hrs |
| Assembling the facts the report form asks for | 8 hrs | 2 hrs |
| Tracking updates, outcomes and the incident reference number | 6 hrs | 2 hrs |
| Recording borderline decisions and reporting them back to trustees | 6 hrs | 2 hrs |
| Deciding whether an incident is serious and should be reported | 6 hrs | 5 hrs |
The shape matters more than the figures: gathering, assembling and tracking shrink, while the decision about seriousness does not. Our NGO platform lists safeguarding, beneficiary records and grants and restricted funds among its modules. Together with workflow automation, which describes approval chains with delegation and escalation when something stalls, and the audit trail, a system can:
- Hold an incident register with the fields the Commission’s form asks for, so the report is filled in from the record.
- Record each decision, including borderline ones decided not to report, with who decided, when and why, and route them to trustees.
- Store external reference numbers: the Commission’s incident reference, police crime reference and any other regulator’s.
- Prompt updates when facts change and escalate if an incident has no recorded decision.
- Produce the year-end view for the annual return declaration: every incident, its status and the trustee decision.
We do not claim to submit reports to the Commission, which uses its own online form. A system keeps the record the form is filled in from. It cannot decide whether an incident is serious, whether to report it, or what to say, and incident records are among the most sensitive a charity holds, so access has to be restricted. The details of what we would build are set in an assessment visit. For the safeguarding duties behind many of these incidents, see charity safeguarding for trustees, and for the data protection side, subject access requests and the complaints clock.

Where to start this week
- Find out where incidents are recorded today. Is there one list, or is it emails and memory?
- Look back over the last year and list anything that might have been reportable. Was each reported, or was there a recorded decision not to?
- Agree who can decide whether an incident is serious, and how borderline decisions come back to trustees.
- Check where the Commission’s incident reference numbers are stored for anything already reported.
- Diarise the annual return declaration and a year-end review of the incident register before it.
This is general information based on the Charity Commission’s guidance (last updated 16 January 2026) as we read it on 12 November 2026. It applies to charities in England and Wales. We have not reviewed the Commission’s examples table, its criminal reporting guidance, the fraud and theft checklist or the data protection section, and it is not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
What is a serious incident under Charity Commission guidance?
The Commission's guidance defines it as an adverse event, whether actual or alleged, which results in or risks significant harm to the charity's beneficiaries, staff, volunteers or others who come into contact with it through its work, loss of the charity's money or assets, damage to its property, or harm to its work or reputation. It says that significant means significant in the context of the charity, taking account of its staff, operations, finances and reputation. The guidance applies to charities in England and Wales.
How quickly must a serious incident be reported?
The guidance says an actual or alleged incident should be reported promptly, which it defines as as soon as is reasonably possible after it happens, or immediately after the charity becomes aware of it. It adds that charities should not wait until someone is arrested, charged or convicted, and that they should report to the Commission even if they have already reported to the police or another regulator.
Who is responsible for reporting?
Responsibility rests with the charity's trustees, although in practice it can be delegated to someone such as an employee or the charity's advisers. The guidance says all trustees bear ultimate responsibility for ensuring the charity makes a report in a timely manner, and that it is the trustees' responsibility to decide whether an incident is significant. Decisions made by others should be reported back to trustees, particularly where an incident was borderline and it was decided not to make a report.
What do you need to include in a serious incident report?
The guidance lists contact details, the charity's name and registration number, reference numbers for any reports to the police or other bodies, the date of the incident and when and how the charity found out, what happened, its impact on beneficiaries, finances, staff, operations or reputation, whether trustees are aware, which policies relate and whether they were followed, and the steps taken to deal with it and prevent similar incidents. It says names and other personal details of individuals are not needed in the initial report.
Is there an annual return declaration about serious incidents?
Yes. The guidance says that if a charity's income is over 25,000 pounds, it must sign a declaration in the annual return confirming there were no serious incidents in the previous financial year that should have been reported to the Commission but were not. Incidents that occurred but were not reported at the time should be submitted before filing the annual return, so that the declaration can be made. The guidance notes the annual return is a statutory requirement under section 169 of the Charities Act 2011.